The Baldwin Group released its Q1 2026 Market Pulse Report, highlighting growing differences across commercial insurance lines as property pricing continued to soften while casualty pressures persisted. The report marks the sharpest divergence in property and casualty pricing trends since the company launched it in Q4 2024.
Property and Workers’ Compensation Continue Softening
According to the report, commercial property pricing declined 7.1% in Q1 2026, reaching its steepest negative reading on record. The company attributed the continued softening trend to strong market capacity and increased competition among carriers. Workers’ compensation pricing also continued its gradual decline, dipping 0.9%.
Leslie Nylund, national managing director of broking and insurance company partnerships at The Baldwin Group, said market conditions are no longer moving in a single direction. She noted that as conditions continue to diverge across lines, understanding how different risks interact has become increasingly important, as decisions in one area can affect outcomes across an entire insurance program.
Casualty Lines Face Ongoing Litigation and Severity Pressures
Several casualty lines continued to face upward pressure during the quarter. General liability pricing moderated to 6.1%, down from 9.3% in Q4 2025, but the report noted that social inflation and litigation trends continued to influence the market. Commercial auto pricing also slowed slightly to 5.7%, although severity drivers such as nuclear verdicts and rising vehicle repair costs remained elevated.
Umbrella coverage pricing increased 8.2% during the quarter, reversing a three-quarter deceleration trend. The report cited continued social inflation pressure and nuclear verdicts as contributing factors.
Cyber and Management Liability Show Mixed Market Conditions
Cyber insurance pricing returned to positive territory at 1.1%, signaling early signs of firming conditions amid increased threat activity. Meanwhile, management liability conditions remained mixed. Private market pricing increased 3.3%, down from 4.8% in the previous quarter, while competition in public directors and officers liability programs continued to push pricing down 3.5%.
Baldwin Report Highlights Growing Segmentation Across Insurance Lines
The report stated that current market conditions are expected to continue throughout 2026. Property and workers’ compensation lines are expected to remain softer, while casualty lines may continue to face sustained pressure. The report also noted that underwriting segmentation has become a defining characteristic of the current market cycle, with underwriters placing greater emphasis on risk quality and documentation.
Nylund added that while the property market continues to provide pricing relief for many insureds, casualty uncertainty remains. She also said that although some areas are showing moderation through selective competition, structural underwriting concerns have not changed. According to Nylund, data and analytics remain important tools for improving renewal outcomes and increasing certainty for underwriters.
Get the latest insurance market updates and discover exclusive program opportunities at ProgramBusiness.com.