Beginning April 3, new 25% tariffs on auto imports are expected to affect multiple layers of the automotive and insurance industries. While positioned as a move to bolster domestic manufacturing and generate an estimated $100 billion annually, the tariffs will likely introduce new cost pressures across the vehicle lifecycle — from imported parts and repair expenses to downstream impacts on claims and premiums.
The implications are particularly important for insurance professionals. With repair costs expected to rise due to the global nature of auto part sourcing, insurers may face an increase in claims severity that could ultimately lead to higher rates. Dealerships and repair shops are also anticipating operational challenges as they manage limited inventories and rising overhead.
What follows is an overview of how these tariffs may influence repair economics, dealership dynamics, and insurance pricing in the months and years ahead.
What the Tariffs Cover
The new tariffs primarily target imported vehicles and auto parts, including engines, transmissions, powertrain components, and electrical systems. With about 60% of auto replacement parts in the U.S. sourced from countries like Mexico, Canada, and China, many routine repairs could become more costly almost immediately. These tariffs will apply not only to new imports but also to the foreign-made components already embedded in the supply chain.
Impact on Vehicle Repairs
Because many U.S. vehicles—domestic and imported alike—rely on globally sourced parts, consumers will likely see rising repair bills. Industry experts note that the costs may hit sooner than expected, especially for parts already under price pressure due to limited availability. Small business owners in the repair sector are preparing to pass along these increases to customers, citing thin profit margins and limited alternatives.
For example, a Georgia-based repair shop owner reported an order for a vintage German part was canceled because of tariff concerns, leaving no domestic replacement options. With many foreign cars on the road, repair shops anticipate significant disruptions.
Dealership Challenges
Dealers, especially those focused on the economy or used vehicles, may also feel the strain. Not only could the cost of importing cars rise, but preparing used cars for resale — often involving foreign-made replacement parts — could also become more expensive. Some dealerships are exploring ways to stock up on parts in advance, though this presents risks if tariffs are later rolled back or modified.
Transparency and customer communication will become even more critical as prices adjust across the market. While some buyers may rush to secure vehicles before price hikes, longer-term pressures on inventory and margins remain.
Insurance Premiums in the Spotlight
The effect of tariffs isn’t limited to upfront car or repair costs. Insurance premiums are also expected to climb—but on a delayed timeline. Industry associations estimate that auto insurance claim costs could rise by $7 to $24 billion annually as repairs become more expensive. Although these increases might take a year or more to reach policyholders due to rate-filing procedures, the upward trend in premiums is already well underway.
Auto insurance premiums rose 14% and 12% in 2023 and 2024, respectively. Before these tariffs were introduced, another 7% increase was projected for 2025, and the actual rate may now be even higher.
A Cost Chain Reaction
While the administration projects the tariffs could generate $100 billion annually and incentivize domestic manufacturing, economists and industry experts caution that global supply chain disruptions will affect more than just new car prices. From repair bills to insurance premiums, the total cost of car ownership may rise in the coming months, regardless of where a vehicle was originally built.
Get the latest insurance market updates and discover exclusive program opportunities at ProgramBusiness.com.