The Connecticut-based Hartford said in a release Thursday afternoon that it “has received an unsolicited, non-binding proposal from Chubb” to acquire the 211-year-old company. Hartford said its board of directors “is carefully considering the proposal with the assistance of its financial and legal advisors.”
In a statement after the market closed, Chubb said the proposal would value Hartford at $65 a share, saying the combination “would be strategically and financially compelling for both sets of shareholders and other constituencies.”
At $65, the offer is 12% above the stock’s opening price Thursday of $57.94. Chubb said it submitted its proposal March 11.
“We have not yet received a response to our proposal but are looking forward to constructive, private discussions in order to expeditiously consummate a fair transaction that benefits all of our respective stakeholders,” Chubb said in the statement.
The offer signals that Chubb’s chief executive officer, Evan Greenberg, is ready for another bold deal.
In 2016, Mr. Greenberg was CEO of business and home insurer Ace Ltd. when he combined it with the then New Jersey-based Chubb Corp. in an approximately $30 billion transaction. The merger turned Chubb into an international powerhouse.
Mr. Greenberg and his team have delivered strong financial results, and Chubb has become one of the biggest global insurers, with market capitalization of more than $75 billion as of Thursday. Its shares were down 2.6% at the market’s close.
After news of Chubb’s takeover approach for Hartford was first reported Thursday by Bloomberg News, shares of Hartford surged. They jumped yet further after the insurer’s midafternoon news release, to finish the day up nearly 19%. Its market capitalization stands at about $24 billion.
Hartford was one of the hardest-hit U.S. insurers during the 2008-09 global markets meltdown. The firm took federal aid, which it has since fully repaid. In the years since, Hartford divested various units to focus mostly on property-casualty insurance for businesses and individuals, offerings for employers’ benefit programs and a mutual-funds business.
Its chief executive, Christopher Swift, made some acquisitions over the past few years as the firm narrowed its focus. Those deals included buying a specialty business insurer, Navigators Group, and a unit from Aetna Inc. that provides life insurance, disability income and other products for companies’ employee-benefit programs.
Before its merger with Ace, Chubb was known by the public as a leading provider of homeowners’ insurance to wealthy Americans through its pricey, but extensive Masterpiece coverage.
Evercore ISI analyst David Motemaden said Hartford was a logical choice for a company like Chubb, which is trying to reinforce operations to insure small-business clients. In a research note, he said Hartford’s small-commercial franchise could complement Chubb’s leading position in insuring large companies, while Hartford’s business of insuring midsize companies would bolster Chubb’s operations in that part of the market.
Hartford said in its release that its board of directors “is committed to acting in the best interests of shareholders over the long term.”