Program Managers vs. Wholesalers: Understanding Their Roles in Property-Casualty Insurance

Program managers and wholesalers are the heartbeat of the Market Directory. It is a content-rich platform connecting wholesalers, MGAs/MGUs, program administrators, and carriers with independent agents looking to place business. Agents use it to quickly make contacts and begin their clients' underwriting, quote, and submission processes.

Published on November 21, 2023

federal backstop program
Federal backstop program for natural catastrophes

This guide explores the vital distinctions between program managers and wholesalers. It explains how each provides unique responsibilities and values within the property-casualty insurance domain. By understanding their roles, you can better leverage these strategic partners to strengthen your risk management options and enhance your insurance solutions. Gaining deeper marketplace insights will also help you get the best results from our robust Program Business Market Directory.

Understanding the Evolving Roles of Program Managers and Wholesalers

Property-casualty insurance is a complex ecosystem of risks, policies, and stakeholders. Program managers and wholesalers are at the forefront of this dynamic industry, two vital players central to the insurance sector's successful functioning and growth.

As insurance technology advances, the roles of program managers and wholesalers become more pivotal for insureds, agents, and brokers, who must manage significant market shifts. For example, surplus line premiums reached nearly $36 billion in the first half of 2023, a 15.9% increase from 2022.

Additionally, the excess and surplus (E&S) market saw a rise to $75 billion in 2022, up 20% from 2021, reflecting growing demand in this sector. The specialized E&S market has also expanded rapidly, growing more than three times the rate of the admitted market from 2016 to 2021 (McKinsey Global Insurance Report 2023). These trends highlight how distribution channels are evolving in the insurance market.

We begin with a review of program managers by outlining their essential responsibilities and the skills they require for effective program management. We’ll follow by summarizing the basic functions and characteristics of wholesalers.

Program Managers: Masters of Specialization and Innovation

Program managers in the insurance sector are entities with the authority to accept applications on behalf of an insurer, underwrite risks, and issue policies. They act as a vital link between insurers and the insured, possessing binding authority for specific lines of insurance coverage. They orchestrate specialized insurance programs and are responsible for building and maintaining relationships with insurers and insured parties.

Program managers are adept at identifying niche markets needing tailored and innovative insurance solutions and addressing those needs by creating, distributing, and underwriting customized insurance programs. They often utilize an uncanny ability to think outside the box and push the envelope when designing programs catering to specific risks, industries, or demographics. Their expertise and understanding of the nuances within these specialized markets allow them to navigate the evolving risk landscape expertly.

By partnering with trusted insurers, program managers can tap into the carrier's unique policy forms, underwriting guidelines, and capacity while providing value-added services such as claims handling and risk management consulting.

As the insurance industry embraces technological advancements, program managers are in an ideal position to leverage these innovations. They can deepen their grasp of evolving risks by utilizing big data, artificial intelligence (AI), and other cutting-edge technologies. This wealth of information enables them to develop adaptive insurance solutions that evolve in tandem with the industry's dynamic nature.

Wholesalers: Providers of Flexibility and Access

In contrast to program managers, wholesalers in the insurance industry act as intermediaries between retail agents and insurers. They provide access to markets and products that retail agencies may not have direct relationships with. Wholesalers excel at offering an extensive range of capacity, breadth of product offerings, and unique insurance solutions, especially when retail agents need to place coverage for hard-to-place, high-risk, or specialized business lines.

In their unique position as intermediaries, wholesalers have developed relationships with many carriers, enabling them to navigate the competitive landscape of the insurance industry efficiently. Their ability to tap into these vast markets allows retail agents to find optimal solutions for their clients, as their services and products fill capacity gaps that carriers may need help to satisfy.

Moreover, as insurance technology revolutionizes the market, wholesalers leverage technology to expedite processes, improve communication, and create more comprehensive insurance solutions. By embracing this technology-driven approach, wholesalers are enabling their partners to provide clients with a detailed understanding of their risk profiles, backed by tailored insurance offerings to match.

Embracing the Future: Combining Expertise and Innovation

The promise of P&C insurance's future lies in merging technology with market insights and specialized skills. Wholesalers adeptly handle varied risks and navigate the E&S market, while program managers offer targeted expertise and direct underwriting for specific groups. This partnership forms the bedrock of an industry poised for proactive risk management through innovative and strategic approaches.

Understanding the complementary capabilities of program managers and wholesalers is critical for those in the property-casualty field. Program managers excel at devising innovative solutions for niche markets, whereas wholesalers bring more insurance product access. Their combined efforts guide the insurance industry toward a future of innovation, efficiency, and adaptability.

As the P&C insurance landscape continues to evolve, the collaboration between program managers and wholesalers remains a cornerstone of this dynamic industry. Their synergy shapes the present and charts a course for a future where you manage your risks with greater intelligence and foresight. If you're a program manager or wholesaler looking to expand your reach and impact in this vibrant market, now is the time to take action.

List Your Program with Us

Are you ready to elevate your program's visibility and connect with a broader network? We invite you to list your program in our directory at Membership is your opportunity to be part of a thriving community where innovation meets expertise. Join us and make your mark in the P&C insurance industry. List your program now to be where the future of insurance unfolds.

About is a leading platform in the insurance industry dedicated to connecting program managers, wholesalers, agents, brokers, and carriers. With a focus on innovation, efficiency, and comprehensive market insights, we offer a unique space where professionals can collaborate, learn, and grow.

Our directory is a vital resource, showcasing a diverse range of insurance programs and services. At, we believe in fostering connections that drive the industry forward, championing a responsive, resilient future, and always being ahead of the curve. Join our network and be part of a community that is shaping the future of insurance.