After several years marked by dramatic increases in property insurance costs across the Gulf region — particularly in Louisiana — businesses are beginning to see some relief. According to industry sources, rates that once tripled or quadrupled in the wake of successive catastrophic storms are now starting to decrease. However, experts caution that the pricing environment remains elevated compared to pre-storm levels and is unlikely to return to previous lows.
Post-Storm Market Disruption
In the aftermath of Hurricane Ida in 2021, property insurance rates in Louisiana experienced unprecedented increases. The storm, characterized by severe wind damage rather than flooding, exposed vulnerabilities in the way insurers had been valuing buildings.
As a result, insurers recalibrated property valuations. For example, buildings previously insured at $85 per square foot were reassessed to a minimum of $115 per square foot. These valuation increases compounded premium hikes, significantly raising overall costs for property owners. In addition to rate and value increases, deductibles rose sharply — from standard 1% to 2% named storm deductibles to 5% across the board.
Market Capacity and Coverage Reductions
Simultaneously, the insurance market experienced a significant contraction in carrier appetite. Many insurers reduced their capacity or declined to serve as primary carriers, offering coverage only at higher attachment points — such as $5 million or $10 million — rather than on the first dollar of loss.
Large property schedules that previously received $30 million in coverage saw that limit reduced to $5 million, often at higher rates. In response to the escalating costs, some policyholders opted to forgo wind coverage altogether or faced difficult decisions about whether to purchase wind deductible buy-downs.
Market Correction Begins
Signs of a market correction began appearing in late 2024. According to reports, property rates began to decline in October or November of that year. Reductions have averaged between 25% and 40%, with some accounts seeing rates cut in half from their 2021–2022 peaks. Despite these improvements, rates remain well above pre-Ida levels.
The recent corrections are encouraging some businesses to reconsider coverage options, including adding wind coverage or buying down deductibles, as previously cost-prohibitive protections become more affordable.
Underwriting Strategies and Data Utilization
In the current environment, detailed underwriting submissions and data modeling are becoming more prominent. Underwriting packages often include building features such as fire suppression systems and roof age to improve placement outcomes, especially in the surplus lines market, where most Gulf property risks are placed.
Probable Maximum Loss (PML) modeling has become a key tool for evaluating appropriate wind coverage limits. Rather than insuring for the total replacement cost of a large property schedule, policyholders may consider a loss limit approach based on modeling data—insuring, for instance, $10 million to $25 million of a $100 million schedule—depending on the risk profile.
Outlook
While the current trend of decreasing property insurance rates marks a shift from previous years of volatility, the structural changes in valuation practices, deductible standards, and carrier capacity suggest a return to pre-storm conditions is unlikely. Businesses and brokers continue to navigate a cautious market, leveraging analytics and strategic underwriting to secure necessary coverage.
Stay informed and ahead of the curve — explore more industry insights and program opportunities at ProgramBusiness.com.