The U.S. insurance industry, already tasked with forecasting risk amid a dynamic global landscape, is now facing new challenges following the announcement of sweeping tariffs by President Donald Trump on April 3, 2025. These tariffs, which include a flat 10% tax on all imports and a 25% duty on imported automobiles and auto parts, are expected to ripple across several insurance sectors, prompting premium hikes and underwriting recalibrations.
Auto Insurance: Premiums Gear Up Amid Parts Price Surge
Auto insurers are facing rising costs as the new tariffs inflate the price of imported vehicle parts. While higher prices for foreign-made cars are one concern, the surge in repair expenses will likely hit hardest. As parts become more expensive to source, claims costs will increase, forcing carriers to rework their pricing models.
Analysts predict auto insurance premiums could rise by 6–10% by the end of 2025. Additionally, the elevated sticker price of new vehicles means higher replacement costs, pushing insurers to reconsider coverage limits and rate structures.
Homeowners Insurance: Construction Inflation Drives Up Coverage Costs
Homeowners insurance isn’t immune from the impact. Tariffs on key building materials—like timber from Canada and steel and aluminum from countries such as China, Germany, and Japan—are projected to increase the cost of both new construction and repairs.
This material cost inflation will raise the price tags on home rebuilds, leading to higher loss payouts for insurers. A home once valued at $500,000 could now cost $575,000 to rebuild, requiring increased coverage limits and, ultimately, higher premiums for policyholders.
Commercial Insurance: Economic Pressure Adds to Risk Profiles
For commercial insurance providers, the ripple effects of rising manufacturing and raw material costs spell broader exposure. Industries reliant on imports may struggle to maintain profitability, which could increase the risk of loan defaults, particularly in the public and infrastructure sectors.
Insurers covering municipalities and publicly funded projects must now reevaluate underwriting assumptions and consider new economic realities in their risk assessments.
Adapting to a Shifting Risk Landscape
To stay ahead of these changes, insurance carriers will need to stress-test their actuarial models and plan for a range of inflation-driven scenarios. Creative underwriting, agile pricing strategies, and scenario modeling will be essential tools in maintaining stability.
As trade tensions and protectionist policies reshape global commerce, the insurance sector must remain vigilant. The effects of tariffs extend well beyond retail prices and job markets—they directly influence the cost and complexity of risk itself.
Final Thoughts
The recent tariff policy marks a pivotal shift in U.S. economic strategy. While designed to support domestic manufacturing, these measures are already exerting pressure on multiple segments of the insurance market. Whether in auto, homeowners, or commercial coverage, insurers must prepare for an inflationary tide that redefines the cost of protection. Proactivity, precision, and innovation will be key to navigating the road ahead.
This blog is based on insights from Bricker Graydon LLP’s article “The Impact of Tariffs on the Insurance Industry,” published on JD Supra.
Stay informed and ahead of the curve — explore more industry insights and program opportunities at ProgramBusiness.com.