Personal cyber insurance is gaining attention as digital threats become more widespread and impactful. Recent research, outlined in the report Addressing the Personal Cyber Protection Gap by Triple-I and Hartford Steam Boiler (HSB), explores both consumer and agent perspectives on cyber risk, revealing a persistent gap in awareness, understanding, and adoption of personal cyber protection. The report compiles key data and survey results to provide a factual, news-oriented overview of the state of personal cyber insurance in 2024.
Increasing Exposure to Cyber Risk in the Home
Cybercrime continues to rise, with the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) reporting over 880,000 complaints in 2023 — a 10% increase from the prior year — resulting in an estimated $12.5 billion in losses. The most frequent type of complaint was phishing, with nearly 300,000 incidents reported. Financial scams followed closely, targeting consumers’ personal and financial information.
Consumers face these threats not only at work but increasingly at home, due in part to the proliferation of internet-connected devices such as smart doorbells, thermostats, and security cameras. These devices may open vulnerabilities that cybercriminals exploit to install malware or extort users. Historically, personal cyber threats were often limited to identity theft, with individuals relying on financial institutions for fraud protection. However, the threat landscape has evolved.
The 2023 HSB Cyber Risk Consumer Study found:
- 3 in 4 consumers have experienced the loss or theft of personal information
- 28% have had social media accounts hacked
- 23% had data compromised in a breach
- 14% experienced some form of online attack
Claims, Financial Loss, and Consumer Impact
HSB reports an average home cyber insurance claim payout of over $10,000. Meanwhile, research from PYMNTS Intelligence indicates that approximately 30% of households have been affected by scams. Among those impacted:
- 69% recovered funds after reporting to their financial institution
- 12% of scams directly impacted financial institutions
The most common scams include tech support fraud, job listing scams, identity theft, and fake eCommerce transactions. Many consumers expressed a psychological toll from such incidents and a declining level of trust in the financial institutions they previously relied on for protection.
Agent Perceptions and the Awareness Gap
Triple-I and HSB’s 2024 survey of retail homeowners insurance agents revealed significant insights into the challenges of marketing and selling personal cyber coverage. While 84% of agents and brokers believe in the value of this insurance, only 43% believe their customers share that understanding. This signals a disconnect between perceived and actual consumer knowledge.
Further findings include:
- 73% of agents say they are comfortable explaining personal cyber insurance
- 68% feel comfortable selling it
- 77% have presented it to clients at least once in the last month
Despite these efforts, adoption remains low. More than half of surveyed agents (56%) reported that customers either do not understand or do not agree with the value of personal cyber insurance.
Pricing and coverage breadth are important to consumers. According to 71% of agents, these are the top two decision-making criteria. Over half of agents believe customers would be willing to pay up to $100 for such coverage — a range in which many endorsements, including those offered by HSB, are currently priced.
Common Cyber Threats Cited by Customers
Agents noted a wide array of threats brought up by customers, including:
- Identity theft and fraud
- Online scams and harassment
- Malware and extortion
- Phishing, ransomware, and data breaches
- Social media hacking and public Wi-Fi vulnerabilities
These responses show consumers are aware of risks, though perhaps less clear on how insurance can mitigate them.
Educational and Strategic Considerations
The data suggests that improving agent training and consumer education could help close the adoption gap. Better awareness of policy specifics — such as what scams are covered and under what conditions — may influence purchasing decisions. Agents who can clearly explain exclusions, deductibles, and coverage limitations may be better positioned to build consumer trust and confidence.
Possible strategies include:
- Providing agents with dedicated training programs and resources
- Offering educational content for consumers on cyber risks and policy options
- Conducting follow-up research through focus groups or broader surveys
Industry Context
HSB provides personal cyber insurance as a homeowners or renters policy endorsement. Services may include ID theft protection, credit monitoring, and risk management tools. Meanwhile, Triple-I, a trusted information resource since 1960, aims to elevate risk literacy and connect insurance professionals and the public through data and education.
These findings underline a growing urgency to address the personal cyber protection gap with proactive communication, informed training, and consumer outreach, ensuring that as digital threats expand, awareness and protection keep pace.
Get the latest insurance market updates and discover exclusive program opportunities at ProgramBusiness.com.