A recent report released by CarInsurent has highlighted significant developments in rental car insurance claims, presenting a snapshot of how the sector is evolving in 2025. The data, compiled through a comprehensive review of claims activity, points to changes in claim frequency, contributing factors, and consumer habits that are reshaping the rental insurance landscape.
Increased Claim Frequency and Causes
Rental car insurance claims have risen noticeably over the past year. This increase is attributed to a greater number of travelers choosing rental vehicles, driven by heightened travel activity and broader use of rental services following pandemic-related slowdowns.
According to the report:
- More than 60% of rental car damage claims are tied to causes outside the renter’s control.
- The average cost charged by rental companies for repairs is approximately $1,169.
- The most common causes of claims include minor collisions, parking lot incidents, weather-related damage, key loss, and misfuelling.
Growth in Third-Party Liability Claims
A growing number of claims now involve third-party liability, particularly in areas with dense traffic and high tourist activity. These claims typically stem from accidents between rental vehicles and private motorists, especially in congested urban settings.
Rising Costs of Claims
The financial burden associated with rental car insurance claims has also grown. Factors influencing this rise include:
- Increased labor and repair costs
- Higher replacement costs due to greater demand for rental vehicles
- Inflation and ongoing supply chain challenges
- More expensive vehicle components, particularly in models featuring advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) or electric vehicle (EV) technologies
While some of these technologies help reduce the severity of accidents, they also contribute to elevated repair and replacement expenses.
Shifts in Consumer Behavior
Renters are demonstrating a stronger awareness of potential liabilities by opting for more comprehensive coverage options. Additionally, there is a clear move toward digital solutions for managing claims, with many policyholders favoring online and app-based submission methods over traditional ones.
Impact of Peer-to-Peer Car Sharing
The emergence of peer-to-peer car-sharing platforms has introduced new patterns in claims, as individuals rent vehicles directly from private owners rather than from traditional rental agencies. This trend is prompting insurers to adapt their policies and risk assessment models accordingly.
Addressing Fraud in Rental Car Claims
The report also notes a rise in fraudulent claim activity. Examples include staged accidents, inflated repair estimates, and misrepresentation of rental timelines. In response, insurers and rental companies are enhancing fraud detection with tools such as artificial intelligence and stricter verification procedures.
Looking Ahead
The trends identified in the CarInsurent report suggest that rental car insurance providers, rental agencies, and consumers alike must adjust to a shifting environment. This includes refining policy structures, strengthening risk assessment protocols, and continuing to educate renters on their coverage and responsibilities.
As demand for rental vehicles persists, data-driven approaches and technology-driven solutions are likely to play a central role in supporting more efficient and reliable rental car insurance services.
For more information about these developments, visit CarInsurent.com.
Stay informed and ahead of the curve — explore more industry insights and program opportunities at ProgramBusiness.com.