Study Says Proposed Catastrophe Legislation Could Cost Taxpayers Billions

According to a joint economic study by Sonecon L.L.C. and the American Enterprise Institute, natural catastrophe legislation that is pending Congressional vote, if approved, would cost taxpayers billions of dollars and displace smoothly operating private and reinsurance arrangements should the U.S. be buffeted by another heavy hurricane season like the one witnessed in 2005.

Published on August 22, 2008

The study finds that under the proposed legislation, in the aftermath of a hurricane season comparable to the one three years ago, sustained losses covered by the federal government would amount to:

* $140 billion to $161 billion in 2009
* $197 billion to $230 billion in 2013
* $278 billion to $332 billion in 2017

The estimated losses would depend on the approach used to set premiums for state programs. However, the cost would ultimately be borne by federal taxpayers.

The study was funded by the Reinsurance Association of America and the Association of Bermuda Insurers and Reinsurers.