As federal policymakers weigh new tariffs on imported goods, the American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA) is sounding the alarm about the ripple effects across the insurance industry and global economic order. According to the trade organization, the proposed tariffs could increase personal auto insurance claim costs by a staggering $30–$60 billion over the next 12 months.
But the concern doesn’t stop at rising premiums. In a detailed commentary, the President and CEO of APCIA outlined how escalating tariffs could destabilize not only the insurance sector but also the broader geopolitical and economic landscape.
Economic Realignment and Global Friction
One of the most pressing concerns is the transformation of global alliances. The CEO notes that divisions between countries are shifting from geopolitical ideologies to economic trading blocs. “The line between allies and adversaries has been blurred,” he writes, highlighting that even strategic partners like Canada and Japan are being pulled into economic friction zones.
This reorientation is creating new tensions among close allies, as countries previously considered politically aligned with the U.S. are now being targeted by tariff policies. The result? Strained international relationships and reduced clarity about who benefits from long-standing alliances.
Tariffs Undermine Southeast Asia Strategy
The new tariffs could also undercut years of U.S. foreign policy aimed at reducing dependence on China. With Southeast Asian nations like Vietnam and Indonesia facing tariffs as high as 30–50 percent, firms that had previously moved operations out of China are now facing penalties. This risks reversing momentum to shift supply chains and political alignment away from Beijing.
“These tariffs punish firms that relocated from China,” the CEO explains, warning that such measures will “greatly undermine efforts to shift the alignment preferences of Southeast Asian states toward the West.”
Repercussions for U.S. Allies and Global Trade
Tariffs may also jeopardize the U.S.’s ability to maintain security cooperation with its treaty allies. Japan, for example, is unlikely to retaliate aggressively but may face internal pressure as its industrial base is hit. U.S. allies could increasingly pursue alternative economic partnerships, reducing their reliance on American trade relationships.
Even if the tariffs are reversed swiftly — a scenario the CEO views as unlikely — the damage to international trust may linger. “It could reinforce the growing perception of the U.S. as an unreliable or self-interested actor,” he warns.
Insurance Industry Impact: Rising Costs and Uncertainty
The implications are immediate and tangible for the property and casualty insurance sector. Many of the inputs for auto and home repairs — including steel, lumber, and heavy machinery — are globally sourced. Tariffs on these goods introduce supply chain disruptions, price volatility, and inflationary pressure.
Although currency fluctuations may absorb some of the cost increases, insurers face heightened uncertainty around claims severity, reinsurance pricing, and long-term asset planning. “Tariffs may not lead to a direct one-to-one increase in costs, but they still introduce friction,” the CEO says.
A Call for Caution and Strategic Foresight
The APCIA warns that policymakers should not overlook the multidimensional risks of aggressive tariff strategies. “It’s not only the announcements themselves,” the CEO notes, “but also the market’s response that ultimately determines the overall impact.”
As the insurance industry prepares for the financial strain ahead, APCIA continues to advocate for a measured and forward-looking approach to trade policy — one that considers not just political gain, but long-term economic and insurance market stability.
Stay informed and ahead of the curve — explore more industry insights and program opportunities at ProgramBusiness.com.